Coinbase, the largest U.S. crypto exchange, has been lobbying the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for clearer crypto regulations for some time. After months of back and forth, the agency responded by announcing an enforcement action - also known as a "Wells Notice."
With a Wells Notice, SEC staff notifies a company that they are recommending that the regulator take enforcement action for possible violations of the securities laws. It is not a formal charge or legal proceeding, but usually results in one. The agency's Wells Notice calls into question specific Coinbase services. The agency classifies some tradable cryptocurrencies, Coinbase Earn, Coinbase Prime, and the Coinbase Wallet as non-registered securities. Coinbase responded to the Wells Notice with its own challenge to the SEC.
Coinbase wants clarity from the SEC
Coinbase is one of the major players in the cryptocurrency industry, with over 68 million verified users and hundreds of billions in annual trading volume. The company detailed its efforts in a blog post and published the response it received from the SEC. According to the post, Coinbase has been pushing for clear regulation that would allow for more innovation in the crypto industry without compromising investor protection. The company had been working closely with regulators to address concerns about issues such as custody, security and market manipulation.
The best articles of the week, directly delivered into your mailbox.Subscribe to our newsletter
In its letter to the SEC, Coinbase requested, among other things, that the authority establish clear guidelines for digital assets. It explicitly requested a definition of which assets are securities and which are not. The company also demanded a regulatory framework that allows the creation of new financial products based on cryptocurrencies, as well as guidelines for the operation of exchanges.
Crypto exchange arguments are ignored
To circumvent these tedious debates, the SEC is increasingly relying on "regulation by enforcement." Instead of defining clear guidelines, the agency is taking legal action against companies it considers part of its jurisdiction. That jurisdiction, in the eyes of Chairman Gary Gensler, is shaping up to be overly broad, encompassing "potentially all cryptocurrencies except Bitcoin." This approach is also reflected in the interaction with Coinbase.
After an investigation began last summer, the SEC approached Coinbase to discuss the possibility of registering a portion of its business with the SEC. Coinbase quickly agreed and proposed two registration models, spent millions of dollars on legal support, and repeatedly asked the SEC for feedback. Although Coinbase met with the SEC more than 30 times, the conversation remained very one-sided, according to the blog post.
When the company asked for feedback on its proposals in December 2022, the SEC said Coinbase could expect to hear back in January 2023. However, the day before the scheduled meeting, the SEC canceled and told the crypto exchange that it would move back to an enforcement investigation. Coinbase suspects disagreements within the commission were key to the SEC's questionable behavior.
Reliable regulation best protects market participants
The lack of regulatory clarity in the crypto industry is causing growing concern among industry players. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is enforcing regulations without providing a clear regulatory framework for the industry. Despite repeated efforts to work with the SEC and develop a registration pathway, crypto companies face a lack of guidance and consistent regulations. Thus, what a "compliant" business model looks like remains unclear. Finally, Coinbase has already undergone a full SEC review in preparation for its 2021 IPO. The crypto exchange's trading and staking services have hardly changed since then, so the SEC's views seem to be new.
"At our core, we are the same company we were on April 14, 2021, when we became a public company ourselves at the end of the lengthy process with the SEC. We remain confident in the legitimacy of our assets and services. If necessary, we welcome a legal process to provide the clarity we have advocated for and to demonstrate that the SEC has simply not been fair and reasonable in its approach to digital assets." - Coinbase Statement
